Director, Site Production
We formed questions specific to Site Team based on the information that they mainly deal with Homepage and receive requests from other teams.
In addition to the original script, we asked the participant of how the one-off content type such as Skin and Template get created.
Interview Script for Site Production Team
We voice recorded the section asking about his daily workflow and screen recorded the demo of his workflow on Toolbelt.
Voice Recording of Site Production Director’s Interview Session
Screen Recording of Site Production Director’s Workflow Demonstration
Role
Site Production Director
- Work with all the different digital departments
- Writers & Editors
- Strategic Content
- Product & Development
- Talk to Product Managers to improve web & video products and Toolbelt
Work function in the team
- small 3-people team
- One producer
- Media creation, e.g. data visualization, charts, graphics
- Long-form special reports, e.g. top states for business
- Another producer
- Breaking News
- Operate as editorial trainer – get new hires up to speed with Toolbelt, explain the workflow
Day-to-day Work
Depends on how the editorial teams flow
- When there is a problem, editorial teams tend to come to them first before going to the technical team
- Package stories together in a higher view
- Help the people when their knowledge is limited in creating certain things on the site
Communication
- TV operation teams
- When there are special needs for the show franchises
- e.g. wants to redesign the entire television section, had to rethink the web templates and processes to updating content – any meetings and back and forth, testing
- Troubleshoot when the content isn’t updating
- Technology team
- Agile meetings – planning for show times
- Product Manager comes for editorial feedback on templates, new homepage design, etc.
- Feedback on process: would the new design of the template affect the editorial resources?
- Slack channel to give feedback on Toolbelt
Prioritization
- Breaking News or live issues, unless there are a group of people working on it already
- Publishing content first
- Other longer term projects in the downtime
- e.g. Visualization producer works with Strategic Content team on their next few upcoming features
Often-used Content Type and Features in Toolbelt
Franchise
- Market
- Make It
Features
- Feed
- Pull from content by tags and surface it on the sections and the landing pages
- Mark-ups like Company, Security, Chart
- Solve other teams’ problems, e.g. can’t find the Company asset to link to, tag ticker, show charts
- Configuration
- Ability to see all the inherited Templates and Skins from the parent
- Parent tab
- Browse the structure from the root
- History tab
- Versioning
- Restore the past version in case people lose their work
- Scheduling
- Publish over the weekend
- Can publish a lot of content at the same time, e.g. articles on 50 states
- Unpublish Wire stories
- Virtual Output List configuration
- Automatically fills with search results
- No need to manually configure the output list for the Franchise
Content Type
- Skins
- Responsible to set these up
- Integrate Javascript code
- Wild Card
- Useful for one-time code
- Flexible – TV teams don’t know the structure of the templates
- Usage Rule
- Use for premium contents – mostly on story level
- Use for syndication contents – DO NOT SYNDICATE rule
- Templates
- Sets brand-specific looks
- Promotional Package
- Allows the creation of content placement that is not ad or in Toolbelt
- Used more in the past to promote different franchises
- e.g. Chartbeat asset with the most popular item on the homepage
- Ability to set up search criteria, e.g. only show up in specific section or on article with specific tags
- Editorial Search
- Used in Configuration – Feed section
- Can set search criteria and filters, e.g. tags, date range, published state
- Webservice
- Embed services like YouTube or Instagram
- WebResource
- Instance of URL
- Create a rankable asset on pages
- Fill in Promotional Headlines and image
Pain Points
- Takes a long time to get information on how successful things are
- Even with tools like Omnishare, it takes a long time to dig deep and wait for it
- Can’t look back a day or a week easily
- Currently getting high-level information from Research team
- Hear complaints about:
- Performance, functionality, and things that are not working that day
- Speed of creating a story or slideshow
- Not an easy workflow for story creation
- Difficult to create stories with a lot of media assets embedded
- Interface isn’t modern
- Feels like a programmer put it together, only thinking about a lot of functionalities
- In comparison with other CMSs, e.g. WordPress
- Image assets are not visual
- Emphasis on things that doesn’t make sense
- e.g. Pull Quote per body takes up a lot of space
- Project Management doesn’t serve any purpose
- Configuration tab isn’t necessary for the regular writers and causes confusion by existing
- Search is complicated and bloated
- Difficult to find something that’s common
- Charting capabilities are limited
- Many fields are useless in the Skin asset
- Parent navigator is too slow
- Iconography is not that great, but knows which one is which
- It takes a while to create Webservice content type
- Often times fall back to Wild Card
Wants
- Better metrics
- Some kind of reporting about the day’s performance
- Wants the statistics information more transparent
- Interested in engagement metrics:
- Video plays
- Unique visitor
- Time spent
- Page views, if ad campaigning
- Reach and where they came from, for stories that have large social impact
- Integrate good charting engine into Toolbelt
- Better workflow for processing images quickly and creating variations of that on the fly, e.g. crops, full-size, etc.
- Strip out the things that are not relevant to the specific asset
- Archiving system
- Doesn’t want to delete them, but doesn’t want the old items to show up in the search
- Should be still searchable
Tools & Software
Communication
- Used to be on multiple channels – IMs, emails, iNews for TV teams
- Slack
- For all digital teams
- Huge lift – allows quick communication, share files & screens and push things around without worrying about distribution
- Dedicated Slack channel to communicate about Toolbelt
- Input for new ideas
- Information about recent launches and things that would impact the editorial team
Charts
- Highcharts
Statistics
- Omnishare
- Chartbeat
- Acts as a dashboard
Work Behavior & Rules
- Knows that Skin’s Primary Assets map to Desktop, and Related Assets to Mobile
- Usually creates a Franchise parent for representational things, e.g. Template, Skin
- Knows that the bullhorned item in the Output List of the Promo Package is being used as part of the package
- Typically set the Frequency of the Feed to Medium, sometimes Heavy depending on the importance
Miscellaneous
- Has been driving people to use Highcharts
- Eliminated a lot of meetings after new Executive Editor came
- Dropping in chart images and tagging became easier in Toolbelt
- Thinks most people probably feel that Toolbelt allows them to do the job pretty well
- New executive editor is very visual in how he likes to tell business news story
- Likes the flexibility of the ability to supplement or overwrite the existing style with Skin asset
- Usage Rules are mainly created by the tech team
- Prime Only Usage Rule is related to video syndication of the Prime team
- Likes the ability to target specific items in the Promo Package
- Can get Breaking News out quickly with Contemplates
- Important to have the flexibility to lock the stories being edited but also to have the ability to kick someone out in emergency